Dissention from Church teaching (liberal & conservative):
A. Liberal (modernist) dissent [links]:
Since the Second Vatican Council in the early 1960s, there has been a growing crisis of apostasy among many Catholics in first world countries. There are many reasons for this, including the tide of secularism that has flooded the Catholic world since the 1960s, the influence of Protestant liberalism (historical criticism of the Bible, etc.) in Catholic schools and seminaries, the influence of the cultural relativism and subjectivism that pervades contemporary culture generally, and the influence of Catholic dissenters and revisionists bent on refashioning the Church along secularist lines, and the confusion resulting from laissez-faire religious education policies within the Church that have increasingly left rank-and-file Catholics confused and ignorant about the Catholic Faith. The following links address a few aspects of this crisis.
B. Conservative (traditionalist) dissent:
As a result of the liberal dissent that has swept the Catholic world since the mid-1960s, a significant minority within the Catholic community have come to regard the Second Vatican Council itself with suspicion, in many cases laying the blame for the ensuing secularization and apostasy upon the Council itself, as well as its popes, whom they in some cases regard as anti-popes, or pretenders to the See of St. Peter. Marcel Lefebvre and the Society of St. Pius X (SSPX) are representantive of this development, and the following links address a few aspects of this movement.
| Do you have a general introduction to the Lefebvrist schism? (James Akin) | |
| Where did Pope John Paul II declare the Society of St. Pius X to be in schism? (James Akin) | |
| Is the decree of excommunication of Marcel Lefebvre available online? (James Akin) | |
| Is the agreement that Lefebvre signed and then welched on available online? (James Akin) | |
| Radical traditionalists have been spreading lies about what John Paul II did in India. What have they said? (Akin) | |
| The Lidless Eye Inquisition ("a weblog dedicated to the exposure of the crackpots of the lunatic self-styled 'traditionalist' fringe who disingenuously pose as faithful Catholics.") | |
| Christopher A. Ferrera and Thomas E. Woods, Jr., The Great Façade: Vatican II and the Regime of Novelty in the Roman Catholic Church, reviewed by James Likoudis |
______________________________________________________________________________________________